Kurt Warner in 2002 struggled with injuries and posted only three passing touchdowns to 11 interceptions, despite being an early draft pick. Anthony Richardson in 2024 was a significant bust, drafted as QB6 but finishing QB26, scoring half the fantasy points of other rookies due to injury and inconsistent play. Patrick Mahomes in 2025, despite being QB6 in ADP, finished as QB10 overall and QB11 in points per game, failing to meet high expectations.