Game-Changing NFL Rules First Tested in Preseason

The NFL often uses the preseason to trial new rules aimed at improving player safety, enhancing gameplay, or addressing strategic concerns before implementing them in the regular season.

The top 3

1. Three Key Player Safety Rules Introduced via Preseason: The NFL has introduced several key player safety rules, often trialed in preseason, including the Dynamic Kickoff and the ban on the hip-drop tackle in 2024, which significantly reduced concussions and lower-extremity injuries. Additionally, the rule prohibiting players from lowering their helmet to initiate contact, implemented in 2018, aims to reduce head injuries.
2. Rules That Most Dramatically Altered Offensive Play: Rules like moving kickoff touchbacks to the 35-yard line (in 2024 and tweaked in 2025) have aimed to incentivize returns and impact field position, thereby influencing offensive starting points. The expansion of replay assist to include penalties like roughing the passer also affects offensive strategy by potentially overturning key defensive plays. Changes to onside kick rules, allowing them at any point when trailing, also offer new strategic offensive opportunities.
3. Most Controversial Preseason Rule Trials: Some rule changes tested in preseason have sparked significant debate among fans and players. The 'Tuck Rule' is a well-known controversial rule that impacted a dynasty. Changes to overtime possession rules, where the first team to score a touchdown automatically won, were met with disapproval from fans and players and were later adjusted. The hip-drop tackle ban, while aimed at safety, has also generated discussion about its impact on defensive play.

Open the full topic